Navigating Selective Workplace Incivility: Insights from Recent Research on Identity and Bystander Intervention
Workplace discrimination, particularly selective workplace incivility, can significantly impact team dynamics. Promoting an inclusive workplace and encouraging bystander intervention are key strategies to address such challenges effectively. In our recent study, led by Jamie L. Gloor, together with Tyler G. Okimoto, Xinxin Li, and Michelle K. Ryan, we shed light on how individual identities, particularly organizational and feminist identities, influence perceptions of and reactions to workplace incivility.
Understanding Selective Workplace Incivility
Incivility, a form of mistreatment that is subtly disrespectful yet pervasive, impacts not just the targets but also the bystanders—individuals who witness but are not direct targets of such actions. Selective workplace incivility means targets are selected based on their membership to a certain group (i.e., women). How bystanders interpret and respond to incivility can significantly influence whether selective incivility persists or is stopped in its tracks.
The (Dark) Role of Organizational Identification
We reveal that individuals with a strong sense of organizational identification are less likely to perceive incivility as discriminatory. This 'dark side' of organizational identification suggests that a deep alignment with one's organization might hinder the recognition of subtle discriminatory practices, potentially allowing such behaviors to persist unchallenged.
Feminist Identification as a Sensitive Sensor for Everyone
Conversely, our research highlights that individuals with a strong feminist identification, regardless of their gender, are more attuned to recognizing discriminatory undertones in workplace incivility. This heightened sensitivity is vital for initiating appropriate interventions and fostering a more inclusive work culture.
Bystander Intervention: A Critical Part of Breaking the Cycle
Intervention by bystanders is a crucial step in addressing and mitigating the impacts of workplace incivility. Our findings suggest that recognizing incivility as discriminatory, and not being blinded by a strong organizational identity, is a precursor to intervention, indicating the importance of awareness and education in empowering employees to act against workplace mistreatment.
Tips for Practitioners
1. Promote Organizational Reflection: Encourage regular self-assessment within the team and organization to understand and address biases that may affect perception of incivility.
2. Foster a Culture of Intervention: Develop policies and training that empower all employees, regardless of their role or identity, to act against incivility.
3. Enhance Awareness: Implement educational programs that highlight the nuances of workplace incivility and its impacts on the organizational climate.
4. Encourage Diverse Identifications: Recognize and value diverse identities within the organization to foster a more inclusive and perceptive work environment.
5. Lead by Example: Leadership should exemplify the values of respect and inclusivity, setting a precedent for behavior within the organization.
By understanding and addressing the dynamics of workplace incivility through the lens of individual identities, organizations can foster a more respectful, inclusive, and productive work environment.
You want even more?
